“They leave us here to die”: HRW report recounts ordeal of more than 12,000 foreigners deported from the U.S. to Mexico
Key Takeaways
- It has been reported that Human Rights Watch (HRW) documented the experiences of over 12,000 non‑Mexican migrants deported from the United States to Mexico and left in dangerous border areas.
- The report alleges widespread abuse: extortion, theft, threats by criminal groups, and failures by Mexican and U.S. authorities to provide protection or safe reception.
- HRW is calling on both U.S. and Mexican authorities to investigate abuses, improve reception and monitoring systems, and halt deportations to places where returnees face serious risks.
- The findings highlight broader policy questions about how the U.S. removes noncitizens and the obligations of transit and destination states under refugee and human‑rights law.
Report findings
Human Rights Watch, according to published coverage, interviewed dozens of people and reviewed official records and other documentation about deportations to Mexico. It has been reported that the organization identified patterns of harm: people—many of whom were not Mexican nationals—were returned to border cities where they faced robbery, extortion, kidnapping and were sometimes forced back across the border by criminal groups. The report alleges that reception facilities and formal assistance were often missing or inadequate, leaving deportees stranded without shelter, medical care or legal information.
Legal and policy context
Deportations and removals in the U.S. are carried out by agencies such as U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP). Asylum seekers and other noncitizens may be placed in expedited removal, detained, or removed by flight. It has been reported that many of the people cited in the HRW report were neither Mexican nor seeking to return to Mexico but were nonetheless sent there; this raises legal questions about protections owed by both the U.S. and Mexico, including non‑refoulement obligations under international refugee and human‑rights law. HRW recommends stronger screening before deportation, greater transparency about removal destinations, and coordination on safe reception.
Human impact and next steps
For migrants and people navigating the U.S. immigration system, the report signals real risks: deportation can mean not just being returned but being put in imminent danger if reception and protection are absent. Lawyers and advocates say this can affect asylum strategies, requests for withholding or protection, and litigation over removal procedures. HRW is calling for investigations and for the U.S. and Mexico to implement reception and monitoring systems so that deportations do not place people in harm’s way. It has been reported that activists and some lawmakers are pressing both governments for immediate policy changes and accountability.
Source: Original Article