Tennessee Senate passes bill criminalizing migrants who defy deportation orders
Key Takeaways
- Tennessee Senate passed a bill (26-6) that would make it a Class A misdemeanor for migrants to remain in the state after a final deportation order; the House earlier approved it 73-22.
- Penalties would include up to 11 months, 29 days in jail, a fine up to $2,500, or both; the bill also criminalizes re‑entry into the state after deportation.
- Supporters say the measure strengthens enforcement; critics warn of federal preemption, legal challenges, and burdens on state courts and communities.
- It has been reported that the bill could become a test case for broader state-level immigration enforcement and might prompt litigation up to the Supreme Court.
What the bill would do
The Tennessee measure requires noncitizens subject to a final removal order to leave the state within 90 days or face a Class A misdemeanor — punishable under the proposal by up to 11 months, 29 days in jail and/or a fine of up to $2,500. It also creates a separate Class A misdemeanor for anyone who re‑enters or attempts to enter Tennessee after being deported. The Senate approved the bill 26-6; the House previously passed the measure 73-22.
Legal questions and federal preemption
Immigration enforcement is primarily a federal power, carried out by agencies such as ICE (Immigration and Customs Enforcement) and adjudicated through federal immigration courts. It has been reported that sponsor House Majority Leader William Lamberth presented the bill as a challenge to limits on state enforcement, saying people who have exhausted appeals and been ordered removed must leave. Critics, including immigration advocates and some legal experts, argue the law could conflict with federal supremacy, a principle known as federal preemption, and that states generally cannot create immigration crimes that interfere with federal removal processes. If enacted, the measure could invite litigation testing those constitutional boundaries.
Human impact and next steps
For migrants with final removal orders — which means their appeals and motions to reopen have been resolved at the federal level — the bill would add a state criminal penalty layer on top of federal removal. In practice, enforcement raises questions: how will Tennessee identify final orders without duplicating federal immigration records; who will bear courtroom and jail costs; and how will communities and employers respond? It is unclear whether Gov. Bill Lee will sign the bill if it reaches his desk. Observers say a veto, signature, or enactment will likely trigger legal challenges that could make Tennessee a focal point in a broader GOP effort to expand state-level immigration enforcement.
Source: Original Article