Sibling sponsorship won’t derail an approved EB‑2 I‑140, attorneys say
Key Takeaways
- Filing a family-based petition (Form I‑130) by a U.S. citizen brother normally does not affect an approved employment-based I‑140.
- EB‑2 (employment‑based second preference) I‑140s are separate from family‑based sibling petitions (F‑4); priority dates and pathways remain distinct.
- Sibling petitions can take many years to reach the front of the queue for countries with backlogs — check the monthly Visa Bulletin for visa availability.
- Nonimmigrant status issues can arise for applicants on visas that require non‑immigrant intent; H‑1B holders generally have dual intent and are less affected.
- It has been reported that Sheela Murthy and other senior attorneys provided the guidance summarized here.
Overview
If your employer-sponsored EB‑2 I‑140 (the immigrant petition filed by an employer on Form I‑140) has been approved, you may wonder whether a U.S. citizen brother can also file a family petition (Form I‑130) for you. The short answer: yes — filing an I‑130 for a sibling (the F‑4 family preference) typically will not cancel or invalidate your approved I‑140. USCIS (U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services) treats employment‑based and family‑based petitions as separate tracks, and approval of one generally does not negate the other unless there is fraud or material misrepresentation in a petition.
Legal detail and timing
Key legal points: a U.S. citizen (age 21 or older) may file an I‑130 for a sibling; lawful permanent residents cannot sponsor siblings. An approved EB‑2 I‑140 gives you a priority date that you can usually retain even if the employer later withdraws the petition, except in limited fraud scenarios. However, approval does not itself make a visa available — you must wait until your priority date is current under the Department of State Visa Bulletin before filing Form I‑485 (adjustment of status) or applying for an immigrant visa abroad. The F‑4 sibling category has historically long backlogs for some countries (notably India and the Philippines), so an I‑130 may not lead to a timely green card for many applicants.
What this means for applicants now
For someone going through the system, filing both routes can be a sensible hedge: the family I‑130 is an alternate path if the employment route stalls, and the approved I‑140 preserves a priority date you may use later. But don’t expect the sibling petition to speed up your immediate adjustment unless the F‑4 priority date becomes current. Also consider your current nonimmigrant status: dual‑intent statuses like H‑1B tolerate immigrant petitions, while B‑1/B‑2 or F‑1 visa holders can face complications if an immigrant intent is evident. Consult an immigration attorney to confirm strategy, monitor the Visa Bulletin monthly, and confirm that the sponsoring brother meets the eligibility requirements to file the I‑130.
Source: Original Article